A Cookie Cutter Christmas

Two longtime rivals and elementary school teachers duke it out during the holidays in a Christmas cookie bake-off, but their real feud ignites over a shared interest in a handsome single dad. With both determined to win the prize and the romance, their competitiveness could jeopardize what matters most this Christmas season.

• 
  Erin Krakow

  Christie Reynolds
• 
  Alan Thicke

  Chef Krueger
• 
  David Haydn-Jones

  James
• 
  Miranda Frigon

  Penny Miller
• 
  Laura Soltis

  Bev Reynolds
• 
  Genea Charpentier

  Lily
• 
  Jill Morrison

  Allison
• 
  Gracyn Shinyei

  Young Christie Reynolds
• 
  Jaeda Lily Miller

  Young Penny
• 
  Emily Delahunty

  Sophia